The Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza has made its annual return to Papa Johns for Halloween 2026.
Available now through November 1, 2026, at participating locations nationwide (and in Canada), the unsliced (to keep the design intact), pumpkin-shaped, thin-crust pizza is decorated with a pepperoni smile and eyes alongside olive pupils.
Prices start at $11.99 in the US and $17.99 in Canada
Crocs US
Jibbitz Spooky Pizza
$4.99
JCPenney
Northlight Led Silly And Spooky Jack-O-Lanterns Canvas Art, One Size, Black
$16.19
Michaels Stores
10ct. Orange Jack-O-Lantern Paper Lantern Halloween Lights By Northlight | 11 ft | Michaels®
$16.99
The Home Depot
Northlight LED Lighted Jack-O-Lantern Happy Halloween Lantern-11"-Black
$19.98
Crate & Barrel
Jack-O-Lantern Small Ficonstone Lantern 8"
$29.99